Anonymous 1:1 · Edition 011 · November 2026

Buyer Perception

They could have twisted my arm. They just didn't call me back.

A Head of Talent Acquisition on the deal a vendor lost by going quiet

Buyer Persona:
Head of Talent Acquisition
Employer:
Services Business
Company Size:
1,001 to 5,000

Technologies covered

ATSCore HRIS

Topics covered

Competitive evaluationDemosPricing & negotiationImplementationCustomer successPeer influence

Stage

EvaluationSelectionImplementationIn-life

Prepared by

Gordon Smith

Founder, Buyer Perception

Buyer Perception

This buyer ran an ATS selection that needed two signatures and no procurement team. One losing vendor was close enough that, in the buyer's words, they could have twisted their arm. Nobody called back. The vendor found out from a LinkedIn post, after the contract was signed. A second vendor cost significantly more and ended the call when asked to explain why. Ask this buyer what vendors wrongly assume TA leaders care about and the answer is cost. Neither of those losses will be recorded that way.

The vendor who won asked what was wrong with the current system and played the answer back, click by click. It was a very strong first impression. It has since been tarnished by a customer success experience that falls short of it: questions that could not be answered on the spot, and meeting times the buyer could not make.

The buyer draws the wider point themselves. Vendors at a recent event brushed them off once the budget didn't fit, without asking who else they might speak to.

“It narrowed it down to two”

You inherited your ATS when you joined. What made you move?

I didn't like the way you organise interviews. I didn't like the interface. I didn't like the way it looked. You couldn't drag and drop a candidate from first stage to second stage to final stage to offer. It wasn't as functional as we wanted it to be, so we moved.

Did you look at anyone else?

We had quite a few. There's a comparison site now, like a price comparison site but for ATSs, and I thought it was quite good. You tell it what you do. We do a bit of volume, a bit of this, a bit of that, multi-user. It narrowed it down to two. It does actually work.

Who has to be involved to get a deal signed?

Me and my CPO did it together. Two signatures. We don't have procurement involved. I'm an expert in this field, and I can negotiate better than they can in some respects because I know where to push.

“They need to know their stuff technically”

What separates a good salesperson from a not so good one?

Engaging. A good deal maker who made you feel valued. The contract was really easy to sign, and they highlighted the changes they'd made, like they promised.

Then I introduced the salesperson to my CPO. You know what it's like when you introduce someone to your manager and you just hope they're not going to say something silly or embarrass you. My CPO asked complicated questions, because that's what they do. What are your most favourable payment terms? I've looked at your contract and it says a data breach is our fault, but what happens if you get breached and our data gets leaked? I didn't even think about that. The salesperson had the answers. They need to know their stuff technically and be personable.

What did they do that the others didn't?

All they asked was: what don't you like about your current system? They wrote it all down and did a like for like. Yours does this, ours does this. They asked me to bring up my current system and show them how I do things in it.

So they were listening, then coming back with the specifics of your situation?

Yeah. And when you listen to someone and then you follow up, that matters. They made a custom video for me. Click, and the video comes up. "You told me you can't add a candidate fast enough. Look what I'm going to do. Done. Took me ten seconds." Easy to click, and it's personable.

Buyer Perception

“They found out when we put it on LinkedIn”

Do the vendors you didn't go with understand why?

No. One of them could have twisted my arm but didn't call me back. Just didn't think I was of that much value. They found out later, when we put the new vendor choice on LinkedIn, and then contacted me. Signed, sealed, contract done. Too late.

What would they have needed to do to twist your arm?

Listened to what we want rather than going on and on with their demo. "If you're hiring for very senior people, we have this model." We don't do that. I'd told them before. We're volume hiring, a lot of it entry-level frontline roles, dozens a month. And they're talking about what you can do if you hire a £250,000 managing director. You can hide it, you can anonymise it. No, no, no. We rarely do that.

But you must have liked enough about it to consider them.

Definitely. It had features I really liked. I would have gone with it, but they never contacted me back. The other guys were a bit more hungry. They're quite on it in sales. I'm giving them a lead now. I'm in a WhatsApp group with other TA people and someone asked if anyone had an ATS recommendation. I introduced them to the salesperson I'd been dealing with.

After you said no, did any of them come back and ask you why?

No.

“We're just expensive. It's our model”

What's one thing vendors think TA leaders care about, but probably don't?

Cost. "We're the cheapest, we can do a deal." Not interested in that. I'm not bothered about saving a couple of grand here and there. We'd rather have a better service. We've probably got the money to pay more, but give us more functionality, tell us what we need and listen to us a bit more.

One vendor on your list was at the top end on price. What happened?

Very good, but way more expensive than the others. They didn't really tell me why they're so expensive. "We're just expensive. It's our model." Well, show me why it's better. "It seems like it's not the system for you. Let's end this call." That's kind of how it went down.

If their CEO asked you for one thing to fix, what would you say?

Better engagement. A better demo. Don't just talk about pricing straight away and rule us out. Ask me what I don't like about my current system and how yours is honestly better. And do a bit of research about us beforehand. One sales rep got what our company does wrong on the call.

I recently bought a car. I walked into the showroom and they said, "We've got one outside. Here are the keys. Take it for a spin." Everything I mentioned I wanted, they showed me the answer in the car. It was half the price of the one we already had on order. I'm not saying that because I'm a cheapskate. The value for money was brilliant. The ATS we chose offered the value for money. The expensive one could have done, they just didn't tell me why.

“Just because your system's not good for me, I could recommend you to somebody else”

You were at a vendor event recently. What did you think of the vendors on the day?

There were some great people and some really bad ones, who just judged you. You can't spend the money, goodbye, next please. How do you know my network isn't huge and I could recommend you to someone? Just because your system's not good for me, I could recommend you to somebody else. It's narrow-minded thinking. You need to be more lateral, especially in the market we're in.

Buyer Perception

“You've got to have someone on the end of the phone”

The sales process went well. What happened after you signed?

The system's great. The salesperson's great. The customer success manager who was assigned to us wasn't the greatest touchpoint for a new system. I've used it before, I know what I'm doing. We've got people who've never used it, who are asking: what is this, what do I click? There are a lot of online videos, but you've got to have someone on the end of the phone. And it's got my name on it, because I brought the system in.

What was lacking, compared with how you've seen it done well?

Our CSM was in a different time zone and was putting meetings in at times that didn't work for us. The next slot was in two weeks' time, and we still couldn't do it. What are we supposed to do in the meantime?

When we asked how to do something it was, "I think you can do this, let me come back to you." You should know the system inside out. We asked to be shown where a setting was. "You have to book a meeting with me, or I can send you a video." We don't want a video, just show us now. We haven't spoken since.

These systems have updates too. They don't really tell you. You get an email. New features. Who's realistically going to read that? They should book something in with you every quarter, and then they could do a bit of an upsell as well. They don't do that.

So next time, you'd meet the CSM before you sign?

I would. Get a call with your customer success manager before making a decision, not just the sales guy. Sales guys are great. You need to check who your full team is. What I don't like is they make you sign something, promise the world, and after that the experience should still be good. Not "we've got your money and that's it."

“I'd rather pay you more so you do a better service.”

Head of Talent Acquisition, Services Business

“Show me a live example of data being moved”

What happened with the data migration?

We're moving candidates across. Sensitive data, and it has to comply with UK law and GDPR. We would have thought they'd be a bit more on it. They were very much, "It's your data. Have you checked with your own IT?" Whoa. You're putting candidate data on a new system. Don't you check?

Had they said they'd take care of it, or had you assumed they would?

They said, "We comply with GDPR." Brilliant. What about data migration? "Don't worry, we handle all that." As soon as candidates come onto the system they get an email and can opt out. Whether they did that, we're a little bit out of the loop. I think they did. We can't go by "think".

Then the import. The names and CVs moved. The rest of the fields didn't populate. Why? "We use a different interface to your old system." What are we supposed to do? "You can do it manually." For thousands of candidates? Good luck.

Next time I'd say: show me a live example of data being moved from this system to that system.

“They told us what we need, even though it cost us more”

You mentioned a really good buying experience recently.

We've just signed for a new HR system and they were absolutely fantastic. From sales to implementation to onboarding. The after-sales needs work in all systems. I don't think anyone's really got it down to a T, apart from these.

They told us what we need. They actually told us it might be a good idea to go out and get an external project manager to help us implement it, which we have. It's cost us a lot of money on top of the system itself. I think it's a bit much, but my CPO doesn't want to take any risks.

And whenever we asked, it was: we can do this, we can do that, we'll show you.

“How do you know my network isn't huge and I could recommend you to someone?”

Head of Talent Acquisition, Services Business

From this interview

2

signatures needed to sign the deal, with no procurement team involved

10 seconds

to add a candidate, as shown in the winning vendor's custom video

2 weeks

wait for the next CSM slot when the times offered didn't work

0

losing vendors who came back to ask why

This edition is part of an ongoing series of anonymous buyer interviews conducted by Buyer Perception. Every participant's identity is protected. No company names, product names, or identifying details are included.

These buyers weren't talking about you. Yours are.

We run the same conversations with your lost prospects and churned customers.

Free 30-minute call. No homework, no commitment.