Anonymous 1:1 · Edition 009 · October 2026

Buyer Perception

They were the only one who did everything

Buyer Persona:
TA Lead
Employer:
Mid-Size Technology
Company Size:
1,001 to 5,000

Technologies covered

ATSAI Sourcing ToolsInterview Intelligence

Topics covered

Evaluation criteriaImplementationCustomer successSales process

Stage

EvaluationSelectionImplementation

Prepared by

Gordon Smith

Founder, Buyer Perception

Buyer Perception

Most vendors compete on features. This buyer chose the one that meant their team could stop switching tabs. A TA leader running a small team across a mid-size technology company, they sat through demo after demo and kept hitting the same wall: every point solution still needed LinkedIn Recruiter, still needed another system open, still broke the workflow somewhere. The vendor that won didn't win on any single capability. It won because the team could work in one place, and because the company's security team felt safer routing AI through a vendor's platform than letting recruiters use it directly.

Gordon Smith, Buyer Perception

“They were the only one who did everything”

How did you end up choosing this vendor over the others you evaluated?

We looked at a lot of tools. We had demos with probably six or seven vendors. But they were the only one who did everything we needed in one platform. No one else covered all of it. And for a small team doing all tech and product hiring, that matters. We can't afford to have five different tools open.

Was it always about finding one platform, or did you start out looking for best-in-breed?

I started looking for specific tools. I needed something to handle the volume of applications coming through the ATS. That was the biggest pain point. But as I looked at more vendors, I kept seeing the same problem. You buy a sourcing tool, great. But you still need LinkedIn Recruiter. You find someone on the platform, but you message them on LinkedIn, and now your tracking is broken. Every tool worked in isolation but nothing worked together.

Buyer Perception

“The more our recruiters could work in one system, the bigger the pull”

So the consolidation argument won over feature depth?

The more our recruiters could only work in one system, that we felt was a massive pull. For a small team, tab-switching is the enemy. If I can do everything in one place, that's a different proposition to having separate tools that each do one thing slightly better but require my team to constantly switch context. We launched recently and already the workflow difference is noticeable.

Does that change how you evaluate new tools now?

It does. If a vendor comes to me now with a point solution, my first question is: does this integrate properly with what we already have, or is it another tab? Because if it's another tab, the bar is much higher. My team has to really not be able to do something before I'll add another system. We're trying to consolidate, not expand.

You mentioned LinkedIn Recruiter is still necessary regardless?

Whichever sourcing tool you use, you still have to have your LinkedIn Recruiter licence. That's the reality. You can find candidates on any platform, but when it comes to messaging, LinkedIn is where you reach them. So any sourcing tool is really an addition to LinkedIn, not a replacement. That's something a lot of vendors don't acknowledge when they're pitching against it.

“If it's another tab, the bar is much higher. My team has to really not be able to do something before I'll add another system.”

TA Lead, Mid-Size Technology

“Everyone talks about agents but most companies can't actually use them”

How do you think about AI tools more broadly in TA?

Everyone talks about these agents and everything, but we're not really allowed to use them. Our security team is very cautious. We can't connect AI directly to our systems. I'm sure most companies are in the same place. Great if you work for a really small company where no one's checking, but most companies of any size can't really utilise them the way the vendors describe.

So how did the AI components of your current vendor get through security?

That's what's interesting. It actually gave our security team comfort knowing it was through the vendor's platform. Rather than each recruiter using AI tokens directly, everything goes through the vendor's infrastructure. They have the compliance documentation, the data processing agreements, the security certifications. Our security team felt safer with that than with us using AI tools individually. And the cost works out better too. Individual AI subscriptions for the whole team would cost more and be less controlled.

There's a lot of vendor focus on sourcing as the problem to solve. Do you agree?

There's a lot of focus on sourcing as a problem. But actually, I don't know that sourcing is a huge amount of the problem. The real problems are application review (the volume coming through your ATS), sourcing your own database (the talent you already have), and streamlined outreach and messaging. Most vendors are building for the wrong pain point. They assume every recruiter's biggest problem is finding people. For us, it's processing the people who've already found us.

Buyer Perception

“The salesperson is massively important”

Does the sales experience matter to you when you're evaluating?

The salesperson is massively important. One vendor was extremely polished. They understood our problems, they could talk about their development pipeline, they knew their product inside out. Another vendor was particularly bad. No product knowledge, no understanding of our situation, just running through a generic script. The difference is night and day, and it tells you something about the company behind the product.

What separates a good demo from a bad one?

Salespeople who've actually worked in recruitment are going to give the best demos. If the salesperson understands recruitment, understands the day-to-day of what a TA team actually does, that comes through. You can tell within five minutes whether someone has lived the problem or is just selling software. The best demos feel like a conversation with someone who's done your job. The worst ones feel like a product tour with someone reading from a script.

Did outreach from vendors ever work on you?

I get outreach constantly. The only one I responded to was someone I already knew from a previous network. General inbox outreach doesn't convert with me. If I don't know you and you're cold-emailing me about your AI sourcing tool, I'm not responding. The vendors who reach me do it through the community, through events, or through people I already trust.

“It really felt as though they understood what we were looking for”

Tell me about the best buying experience you've had. What made it work?

The vendor we chose. They understood what we were looking for and they could talk about what they were building next, what was on their roadmap, and it aligned with where we were going. That level of investment in the relationship before you've even signed is rare.

What about after the sale? How has the support been?

We have a direct Slack channel with our customer success person. If something isn't working, I message them and it gets sorted that day. Not a ticket system, not a weekly check-in call where you run through an agenda. Direct, instant communication. That makes a huge difference compared to just getting a weekly call with someone reading through a dashboard. I've had vendors where you wait three days for a response to a support ticket. This is completely different.

You mentioned a vendor you liked but didn't choose. What happened there?

I liked the product a lot. The founder was someone I knew from a previous network, which helped. But the integration we needed wasn't ready yet, and my manager felt the company was too early-stage for where we were going. So the product was good, the relationship was good, but the readiness wasn't there. If they'd been further along, it might have been different.

From this interview

6–7 vendors evaluated

before choosing the only one that covered everything in one platform

1 platform

chosen over every point solution because the team couldn't afford to switch tabs

LinkedIn Recruiter

still required regardless of sourcing tool; no vendor replaces it for messaging

0 coordinators

no recruitment coordinators, making scheduling the next pain point

This edition is part of an ongoing series of anonymous buyer interviews conducted by Buyer Perception. Every participant's identity is protected. No company names, product names, or identifying details are included.

These buyers weren't talking about you. Yours are.

We run the same conversations with your lost prospects and churned customers.

Free 30-minute call. No homework, no commitment.