Anonymous 1:1 · Edition 008 · October 2026

Buyer Perception

Just show me what it does for my specific situation and stop acting like you've invented something nobody's ever thought of.

Buyer Persona:
Senior TA leader
Employer:
Large Enterprise
Company Size:
10,000+

Technologies covered

ATSAI Sourcing Tools

Topics covered

Evaluation criteriaSales processProcurementCustomer success

Stage

EvaluationIn-lifeRenewal

Prepared by

Gordon Smith

Founder, Buyer Perception

Buyer Perception

Most vendors assume the hardest part of selling to enterprise is getting the buyer to say yes. This buyer evaluates new technology on an ongoing basis. They run TA technology across a 10,000-person company. They know what they want. The harder part is what comes after they like the product: getting it past security, compliance, data protection, and finance. When a vendor can't produce the answers those teams need, this buyer doesn't fight for them. The deal dies inside the buyer's own organisation, and the vendor never sees it happen.

Gordon Smith, Buyer Perception

“I would take the recommendation of a peer before going to look at what it says on the grid”

How do you find new vendors and keep up with what's out there?

I'm always looking. I keep on top of what's happening through industry peer communities, through conferences and events, and through analyst reports. I would take the recommendation of a peer before going to look at what it says on any grid. The grids are interesting, but you have to question the independence when the companies on them are paying a lot of money to be evaluated.

So peer recommendation carries more weight than published analysis?

Every time. If someone in my network says they've used something and it's been good, I'll look at it. If it's just ranked highly on a grid but nobody I trust has actually tried it, I'll note it but I'm not rushing to book a demo. My peer communities are where I get the honest picture.

“I'm not going to fight internally for the product if they don't make it easy for me”

Senior TA leader, Large Enterprise

“Security, governance, and compliance is up there because it needs to be. Without that, you pass or fail”

What's the first thing you look at when you're evaluating a new vendor?

Security, governance, and compliance is up there because it needs to be. Without that, you pass or fail. Those are the first questions I ask. I can end an evaluation right there. If you can't answer the security questions, we're done.

Has that always been the case?

It's changed. I used to own the budget and the procurement decision. Now it goes through data protection, compliance, InfoSec, security, and finance. All of those teams need to sign off. So the vendor doesn't just need to convince me. They need to give me the ammunition to get them through five other teams. And most of them don't even think about that.

What does that look like in practice?

They need to be able to receive a security questionnaire and complete it properly. Startups really struggle with this because they can't handle enterprise questionnaires. If I send you a 200-question security form, you need answers at your fingertips. Not "we'll get back to you." At your fingertips. The products need to be enterprise ready.

Buyer Perception

“I'm not going to fight internally for the product if they don't make it easy for me”

So the vendor has to help you navigate their own way in?

If I don't care enough about the product and I've got a million and one things to do, I'm not going to fight internally for the product if they don't make it easy for me to get that information and do a lot of the legwork. It has to be easy for me to bring them in. If they can't produce the compliance documentation, if they can't fill out the security forms, if every question I ask takes a week to come back, I'm moving on. There are other options that make it straightforward.

And the vendor wouldn't know that's why they lost the deal?

Probably not. They'd think I went quiet or chose someone else on features. But the product might have been fine. I just wasn't going to spend my time chasing their paperwork when I've got other vendors who can handle it.

Is this a recent change in how enterprise buying works?

The number of people involved in signing off a new technology purchase has grown. A few years ago I'd have made the call myself. Now I need five separate teams to say yes, and every one of them has a list of questions. If the vendor isn't ready for that, they don't get through. It's not personal. I just have too many things on my plate to carry someone through a process they should have been prepared for.

“Three separate people over the course of two months”

Has a vendor's sales process ever put you off, even when you liked the product?

I really liked the look of one product, but three separate people over the course of two months. I was like, sorry, that's not going to fly. If you can't organise your own sales team, what's the implementation going to look like? That's how I read it. It's a signal.

You take the sales experience as a proxy for what comes after?

Completely. If a product comes in and lands and it's implemented, it's brilliant, who looks good? The person who brought it in. If it fails, it's also their accountability. So I'm looking at how the vendor runs themselves. Three handovers before I've even signed anything tells me something about how they'll handle my account afterwards.

Does the selling style matter too?

The one line I wish every vendor would stop using: "Isn't this fantastic? Have you ever seen anything like this before?" Yes. I have. Everyone has to appreciate that we've all seen AI now. It's not new to me. Just show me what it does for my specific situation and stop acting like you've invented something nobody's ever thought of.

Is there a pattern to which vendors struggle with this?

Each country and region has its own selling and buying culture, and vendors should appreciate that and adapt. Selling in North America is not the same as selling in Europe or in Asia. Some vendors are very quick to brush over what I believe are big things. "We'll come back to you on that." Trying to nail down the next meeting when I've already told them I'm not interested based on what I've seen. And then you're seeing a lot of people who've never worked in TA try to build TA products. They see that recruitment's broken and think they can fix it with technology, but they don't understand the problem they're solving.

Buyer Perception

“The best sell for me would be if the TA person you're trying to sell to wants to work at your company”

Tell me about a good buying experience. What made it work?

The best sell for me would be if the TA person you're trying to sell to wants to work at your company. That tells you something about the culture, the people, the way they operate. I gave that feedback directly to my current vendor. One call they brought their internal recruiter along and that was very powerful. It showed me how they use their own product, how their team operates, what it's like on the inside.

What else did that vendor do well?

Excellent customer service. I've had access to their senior leadership, their head of marketing, their head of product. If something isn't working, I can pick up the phone and it gets sorted. That's not common. I've had other vendors where you're passed around three different account managers in a year and each one starts from scratch. That destroys any relationship you've built.

Did the commercial side of the decision matter?

Seventy per cent of my decision was product and fit. Thirty per cent was commercial viability. You need both, but if the product doesn't work, the price doesn't matter. I nearly left them sixteen months ago. Gave them an ultimatum on their AI features. They caught up. If they hadn't, the price wouldn't have saved them.

If you could give one piece of advice to the revenue leaders at HR tech companies, what would it be?

Listen to what the users and the customers actually want and need, and then pick your battles. Every company is rushing to get their AI features out without actually understanding if it's going to be a benefit. Some of them are just very generic. I've seen a lot that go, "Oh, we can do this." Well, yeah, so can every company now. That becomes standard. It's not an added bonus anymore. And they need to appreciate that companies like mine are now thinking, can we build it ourselves with our own AI? So vendors have to be very careful about what they're offering and why it's worth paying for.

From this interview

5 sign-off teams

the number of internal teams that must approve before a vendor gets through

3 people in 2 months

the sales process that killed a deal the product had won

70/30

product-and-fit vs commercial viability in the buying decision

16 months

from ultimatum to renewal, after the vendor delivered on AI

This edition is part of an ongoing series of anonymous buyer interviews conducted by Buyer Perception. Every participant's identity is protected. No company names, product names, or identifying details are included.

These buyers weren't talking about you. Yours are.

We run the same conversations with your lost prospects and churned customers.

Free 30-minute call. No homework, no commitment.